• Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Support Us
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Meghalya Government
South Asia Views
Meghalya Tourism
  • Home
  • State
  • North East
    • All
    • Arunachal Pradesh
    • Assam
    • Manipur
    • Meghalaya
    • Mizoram
    • Nagaland
    • Sikkim
    • Tripura
    29 TMC candidates file nominations today, asserting to bring winds of change in the state

    29 TMC candidates file nominations today, asserting to bring winds of change in the state

    Dr. Mukul goes all out against NPP-led MDA government; raises flak over lack of development in the state

    Dr. Mukul goes all out against NPP-led MDA government; raises flak over lack of development in the state

    6 JD(U)  MLAs join BJP in Arunachal Pradesh

    Assembly Polls 2023 : BJP reposes trust on its candidates

    Congress says NPP ruined state finances; Proposes to set up state university for job oriented courses

    Congress says NPP ruined state finances; Proposes to set up state university for job oriented courses

    Assembly Polls 2023 : CM Conrad  files nomination to contest from South Tura Seat

    Assembly Polls 2023 : CM Conrad files nomination to contest from South Tura Seat

    Tripura Assembly Polls: Union Minister holds door-to-door campaign in Dhanpur

    Tripura Assembly Polls: Union Minister holds door-to-door campaign in Dhanpur

    Chief Minister should apologise  for his racial remarks against TMC: Dr. Mukul

    Chief Minister should apologise for his racial remarks against TMC: Dr. Mukul

    6 JD(U)  MLAs join BJP in Arunachal Pradesh

    Assembly Polls 2023 : BJP seeks suggestions for ‘People’s Manifesto ‘

    Assembly Polls 2023 : Former Speaker Martin M Danggo  joins BJP

    Assembly Polls 2023 : Former Speaker Martin M Danggo joins BJP

    Trending Tags

    • National
      Air Marshal AP Singh takes over as  Vice Chief Of  Air Staff

      Air Marshal AP Singh takes over as Vice Chief Of Air Staff

      National Voters’ Day to be celebrated on Wednesday

      National Voters’ Day to be celebrated on Wednesday

      Media Reports claiming ‘multiple side-effects of COVID19 vaccines’ are false

      Meghalaya Launches its First Drone Station for Delivery of healthcare items

      Meghalaya Launches its First Drone Station for Delivery of healthcare items

      Divinity of India will pave the way for a peaceful world : PM Modi

      Divinity of India will pave the way for a peaceful world : PM Modi

      Longest serving Indian -origin MP wants Amitabh Bachchan to be honoured by Britain

      Longest serving Indian -origin MP wants Amitabh Bachchan to be honoured by Britain

      PM Modi announces a new initiative – PM SHRI Schools on the occasion of Teachers’ Day

      PM Modi announces a new initiative – PM SHRI Schools on the occasion of Teachers’ Day

      Droupadi Murmu  becomes India’s first tribal woman President

      Droupadi Murmu becomes India’s first tribal woman President

      Opinion I India readies to welcome a tribal President

      Opinion I India readies to welcome a tribal President

    • South Asia
      BSF rescues  25 cattle along Indo -Bangla border in East Khasi Hills

      BSF rescues 25 cattle along Indo -Bangla border in East Khasi Hills

      BSF nabs 2 cattle smugglers along Indo -Bangla border

      BSF nabs 2 cattle smugglers along Indo -Bangla border

      BSF seizes cosmetics worth  Rs 47 lakh along Indo – Bangla border

      BSF seizes cosmetics worth Rs 47 lakh along Indo – Bangla border

      BSF seizes cosmetics worth Rs  4.30 Lakh  along Indo -Bangla border

      BSF seizes cosmetics worth Rs 4.30 Lakh along Indo -Bangla border

      BSF seizes betelnut worth Rs 24 lakh in South Garo Hills

      BSF seizes betelnut worth Rs 24 lakh in South Garo Hills

      BSF seizes 300 kgs of human hair worth 30 lakh

      BSF seizes 300 kgs of human hair worth 30 lakh

      BSF hands over a Bangladeshi minor boy to Bangladeshi  Border Guards

      BSF hands over a Bangladeshi minor boy to Bangladeshi Border Guards

      State holds Program to Celebrate the Communities of Meghalaya

      State holds Program to Celebrate the Communities of Meghalaya

      BSF seizes luxury items worth  Rs 38 lakhs  along Indo -Bangla border at Pyrdwah

      BSF seizes luxury items worth Rs 38 lakhs along Indo -Bangla border at Pyrdwah

    • Business
    • Sports
      Senior Women’s One Day Trophy: Meghalaya beaten by West Bengal

      Senior Women’s One Day Trophy: Meghalaya beaten by West Bengal

      Basketball & Tennis tournament underway at Raj Bhavan

      Basketball & Tennis tournament underway at Raj Bhavan

      Ranji Semifinal: Meghalaya set massive target to beat Bihar

      Ranji Semifinal: Meghalaya set massive target to beat Bihar

      Ranji  Semifinal: Bihar tighten the screws against Meghalaya

      Ranji Semifinal: Bihar tighten the screws against Meghalaya

      Ranji  Semifinal: Meghalaya made to slog as Bihar hit 300-plus on Day 1

      Ranji Semifinal: Meghalaya made to slog as Bihar hit 300-plus on Day 1

      Meghalaya to host historic Ranji Trophy Plate Group semifinal from Tuesday

      Meghalaya to host historic Ranji Trophy Plate Group semifinal from Tuesday

    • Opinion
    • Meghalaya Tourism
    • Home
    • State
    • North East
      • All
      • Arunachal Pradesh
      • Assam
      • Manipur
      • Meghalaya
      • Mizoram
      • Nagaland
      • Sikkim
      • Tripura
      29 TMC candidates file nominations today, asserting to bring winds of change in the state

      29 TMC candidates file nominations today, asserting to bring winds of change in the state

      Dr. Mukul goes all out against NPP-led MDA government; raises flak over lack of development in the state

      Dr. Mukul goes all out against NPP-led MDA government; raises flak over lack of development in the state

      6 JD(U)  MLAs join BJP in Arunachal Pradesh

      Assembly Polls 2023 : BJP reposes trust on its candidates

      Congress says NPP ruined state finances; Proposes to set up state university for job oriented courses

      Congress says NPP ruined state finances; Proposes to set up state university for job oriented courses

      Assembly Polls 2023 : CM Conrad  files nomination to contest from South Tura Seat

      Assembly Polls 2023 : CM Conrad files nomination to contest from South Tura Seat

      Tripura Assembly Polls: Union Minister holds door-to-door campaign in Dhanpur

      Tripura Assembly Polls: Union Minister holds door-to-door campaign in Dhanpur

      Chief Minister should apologise  for his racial remarks against TMC: Dr. Mukul

      Chief Minister should apologise for his racial remarks against TMC: Dr. Mukul

      6 JD(U)  MLAs join BJP in Arunachal Pradesh

      Assembly Polls 2023 : BJP seeks suggestions for ‘People’s Manifesto ‘

      Assembly Polls 2023 : Former Speaker Martin M Danggo  joins BJP

      Assembly Polls 2023 : Former Speaker Martin M Danggo joins BJP

      Trending Tags

      • National
        Air Marshal AP Singh takes over as  Vice Chief Of  Air Staff

        Air Marshal AP Singh takes over as Vice Chief Of Air Staff

        National Voters’ Day to be celebrated on Wednesday

        National Voters’ Day to be celebrated on Wednesday

        Media Reports claiming ‘multiple side-effects of COVID19 vaccines’ are false

        Meghalaya Launches its First Drone Station for Delivery of healthcare items

        Meghalaya Launches its First Drone Station for Delivery of healthcare items

        Divinity of India will pave the way for a peaceful world : PM Modi

        Divinity of India will pave the way for a peaceful world : PM Modi

        Longest serving Indian -origin MP wants Amitabh Bachchan to be honoured by Britain

        Longest serving Indian -origin MP wants Amitabh Bachchan to be honoured by Britain

        PM Modi announces a new initiative – PM SHRI Schools on the occasion of Teachers’ Day

        PM Modi announces a new initiative – PM SHRI Schools on the occasion of Teachers’ Day

        Droupadi Murmu  becomes India’s first tribal woman President

        Droupadi Murmu becomes India’s first tribal woman President

        Opinion I India readies to welcome a tribal President

        Opinion I India readies to welcome a tribal President

      • South Asia
        BSF rescues  25 cattle along Indo -Bangla border in East Khasi Hills

        BSF rescues 25 cattle along Indo -Bangla border in East Khasi Hills

        BSF nabs 2 cattle smugglers along Indo -Bangla border

        BSF nabs 2 cattle smugglers along Indo -Bangla border

        BSF seizes cosmetics worth  Rs 47 lakh along Indo – Bangla border

        BSF seizes cosmetics worth Rs 47 lakh along Indo – Bangla border

        BSF seizes cosmetics worth Rs  4.30 Lakh  along Indo -Bangla border

        BSF seizes cosmetics worth Rs 4.30 Lakh along Indo -Bangla border

        BSF seizes betelnut worth Rs 24 lakh in South Garo Hills

        BSF seizes betelnut worth Rs 24 lakh in South Garo Hills

        BSF seizes 300 kgs of human hair worth 30 lakh

        BSF seizes 300 kgs of human hair worth 30 lakh

        BSF hands over a Bangladeshi minor boy to Bangladeshi  Border Guards

        BSF hands over a Bangladeshi minor boy to Bangladeshi Border Guards

        State holds Program to Celebrate the Communities of Meghalaya

        State holds Program to Celebrate the Communities of Meghalaya

        BSF seizes luxury items worth  Rs 38 lakhs  along Indo -Bangla border at Pyrdwah

        BSF seizes luxury items worth Rs 38 lakhs along Indo -Bangla border at Pyrdwah

      • Business
      • Sports
        Senior Women’s One Day Trophy: Meghalaya beaten by West Bengal

        Senior Women’s One Day Trophy: Meghalaya beaten by West Bengal

        Basketball & Tennis tournament underway at Raj Bhavan

        Basketball & Tennis tournament underway at Raj Bhavan

        Ranji Semifinal: Meghalaya set massive target to beat Bihar

        Ranji Semifinal: Meghalaya set massive target to beat Bihar

        Ranji  Semifinal: Bihar tighten the screws against Meghalaya

        Ranji Semifinal: Bihar tighten the screws against Meghalaya

        Ranji  Semifinal: Meghalaya made to slog as Bihar hit 300-plus on Day 1

        Ranji Semifinal: Meghalaya made to slog as Bihar hit 300-plus on Day 1

        Meghalaya to host historic Ranji Trophy Plate Group semifinal from Tuesday

        Meghalaya to host historic Ranji Trophy Plate Group semifinal from Tuesday

      • Opinion
      • Meghalaya Tourism
      No Result
      View All Result
      South Asia Views
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home Opinion

      Uniform Civil Code : Triumphalism or Homogeneity

      In Meghalaya, NPP has clearly opposed the code ahead of the crucial assembly polls in the tribal-majority state, much to the chagrin of its alliance partner BJP

      sav_editor by sav_editor
      January 20, 2023
      in Featured, Flash News, Meghalaya, North East
      0
      Meghalaya govt further slashes prices of petrol & diesel ;  Load Shedding  completely  removed

      Meghalaya Chief Minister Conrad K . Sangma .

      339
      SHARES
      2k
      VIEWS

      By Chiranjib Haldar

      There are two crucial facets of the contentious Uniform Civil Code. First, is uniformity even desirable for as diverse a nation as India? Second, is tinkering with the constitutional protection granted for personal laws of every religion appropriate in a country like ours? The Supreme Court has allowed Uniform Civil Code panels in Gujarat and Uttarakhand, refusing to intervene in the matter and dismissing public interest litigations on the issue.

      In Meghalaya, NPP has clearly opposed the code ahead of the crucial assembly polls in the tribal-majority state, much to the chagrin of its alliance partner BJP. Whereas Hindu personal laws are based on religious texts like the Vedas, Upanishads, Gita and scriptures, rooted in Dharma, Muslim personal laws are based on the Shariat Application Act,1937. Christian Personal laws are either based on the Mosaic Law and Ten Commandments of the Old Testament or on the canon law in the Catholic, Anglican and Orthodox churches. And the commonality is they all refer to practices that define living in a society.

      Are personal laws based on religion an affront to the nation’s unity or would the implementation of a Uniform Civil Code put the country’s secular fabric in jeopardy? Political chaos in houses of parliament over this controversial bill is nothing new.

      Article 44, part 4 of the Indian constitution reads ‘The State shall endeavour to secure for the citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India.’ The Code is a proposal to ‘formulate and implement personal laws of the citizens which will be applicable to every Indian irrespective of caste, religion and sexual orientation.’ Under it, all personal matters such as marriage, divorce, adoption, inheritance and succession will be dealt with uniformly for all persons. The government’s basic premise being that a much-delayed Uniform Civil Code will ensure the integration of India by bringing different communities on a common platform.

      While India does have uniformity in most criminal and civil matters like the Criminal Procedure Code and Civil Procedure Code, the laws of anticipatory bail differ from one state to another. Experts opine that if there is plurality in already codified civil and criminal laws, the concept of ‘one nation, one law’ cannot be applied to diverse personal laws of various communities.

      In the famous Shah Bano judgement of 1985, where a divorced Muslim woman asked for alimony from her ex- husband, the Supreme Court did not abide by Muslim Personal Law and called for implementation of the UCC. In 2018, the Law Commission had submitted a treatise on reform of family laws in all religions.

      Votaries against the code argue that the obvious objective behind letting loose the Uniform Civil Code genie now is to get certain sections worked up, especially the minorities and to reap dividends by keeping the polarisation pot steaming. With Article 370 abrogated, the Ram temple construction at Ayodhya in full swing, the code may be the most potent weapon left in the BJP’s arsenal. When the Supreme Court quashed the validity of instant triple talaq, the BJP leadership went into raptures and gave a thumbs-up to formulate a Uniform Civil Code.

      ADVERTISEMENT

      There are genuine apprehensions that a uniform civil code would ultimately be less about uniformity and equality and more about encroaching on the personal laws of minority and tribal communities.  If the framers of the Constitution had intended to have a uniform civil code, they would have included personal laws in the Union List and not in the Concurrent List. Even B.R. Ambedhkar had an ambivalent stance toward the UCC. He felt that though desirable, the UCC should remain ‘purely voluntary’ in the initial stages and would not impose on all citizens.

      The dichotomy remains 75 years after independence. Do secular liberals oppose a pan-India civil code only because it comes from the BJP or do they uphold it? If majoritarian triumphalism overpowers secular liberalism, there will be opposition to the Uniform Civil Code when the devil emerges in its fine print. By introducing the Uniform Civil Code bill, the BJP may be gradually striding towards fulfilling its grandstanding agenda.

      There is a Scylla and Charybdis in the Uniform Civil Code. Home Minister Amit Shah has reiterated that the UCC has always been on the party’s agenda since its inception and that ‘Religion cannot be the basis of the law of the land’. If the Uniform Civil Code is used as a tool of coercion to enforce regressive, upper-caste Hindu cultural and religious practices on everybody in the country, then there may certainly be vehement protest against it. And liberals of all stripes would be at the frontline of that upheaval because then such a law would be illiberal, neither secular nor progressive. It would be another display of brute majoritarianism and a blatant show of regressive postures towards select communities.

      The Code is hairbrained in the sense of not being a buffer against gender injustice. Opponents fear that in the long run it can soft-pedal nationalist agenda of a genre to discipline those distressed. But is the UCC actually a safeguard to save women from discrimination? In India, marriage is considered a sacrament in Hinduism, a contract in Islam, a compulsory registration in Zoroastrianism and divorce stigmatised in Christianity. Those who are demanding it on specious grounds of emancipating women of certain communities perhaps know that it would remain a pipe-dream. A secular civil code may be the need of the hour but apologists for the current dispensation may not be willing to shed their ideological tag. And for the crores of tribals, a uniform civil code directly impinges on their specific customs including polyandry, polygamy and their anthropogenic practices. Various opposition parties thus fear the Bill would be stamped by a brute majority to create further polarisation and turmoil.

      Is it time to depoliticise the status quo that has persisted around the viability and enactment of the Uniform Civil Code? If we recapitulate, ‘The Queen’s 1859 Proclamation’ promised absolute abstinence and non-interference in religious matters. The British government established uniform laws for crimes, evidence and contracts, but personal laws of Hindus and Muslims were left to their discretion. It is an arduous task for politicians to evolve a consensus and legislate on the Uniform Civil Code amidst a heterogeneous, diverse and pluralistic polity. Many argue that societal mainstreaming can only commence with the conferment of this code. And should the code be passed by this regime, given its mandate and political will, it will albeit subsume existing privacy laws in silos, which are based on religion or caste.

       

      (The writer is a commentator on politics and society and has had substantive stints in broadcast media.)

      Previous Post

      NEHU VC meets Union Minister of Education

      Next Post

      Opinion I The Role of the Press in the Hill State movement 1952-1972

      sav_editor

      sav_editor

      Related Posts

      29 TMC candidates file nominations today, asserting to bring winds of change in the state
      Meghalaya

      29 TMC candidates file nominations today, asserting to bring winds of change in the state

      by sav_editor
      February 6, 2023
      Dr. Mukul goes all out against NPP-led MDA government; raises flak over lack of development in the state
      Meghalaya

      Dr. Mukul goes all out against NPP-led MDA government; raises flak over lack of development in the state

      by sav_editor
      February 5, 2023
      6 JD(U)  MLAs join BJP in Arunachal Pradesh
      Meghalaya

      Assembly Polls 2023 : BJP reposes trust on its candidates

      by sav_editor
      February 5, 2023
      Congress says NPP ruined state finances; Proposes to set up state university for job oriented courses
      Meghalaya

      Congress says NPP ruined state finances; Proposes to set up state university for job oriented courses

      by sav_editor
      February 5, 2023
      Assembly Polls 2023 : CM Conrad  files nomination to contest from South Tura Seat
      Meghalaya

      Assembly Polls 2023 : CM Conrad files nomination to contest from South Tura Seat

      by sav_editor
      February 5, 2023
      Next Post
      Assam Covid -19 : 55 more fatalities , 4,826 fresh cases in past  24 hours

      Opinion I The Role of the Press in the Hill State movement 1952-1972

      Meghalaya Day celebrated

      Meghalaya Day celebrated

      Assembly Polls  2023 : NPP launches poll campaign from  Adokgre

      Assembly Polls 2023 : NPP launches poll campaign from Adokgre

      Leave a Reply Cancel reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      We’re on Facebook

      Advertisement

      Popular Post

      • 29 TMC candidates file nominations today, asserting to bring winds of change in the state

        29 TMC candidates file nominations today, asserting to bring winds of change in the state

        335 shares
        Share 134 Tweet 84
      • Assembly Polls 2023 : CM Conrad files nomination to contest from South Tura Seat

        336 shares
        Share 134 Tweet 84
      • National Highway – 62 to finally get underway, land acquisition to begin soon

        601 shares
        Share 240 Tweet 150
      • A tribute to Khasi folk legend Kerios Wahlang

        417 shares
        Share 167 Tweet 104
      • Meghalaya : Rs 55 lakh missing from man’s account in Meghalaya Rural Bank

        417 shares
        Share 167 Tweet 104
      Facebook Twitter Youtube Instagram

      About Us

      South Asia Views is the new spokesman of not an endangered world, but that of cosmic fusion, a new bearer of the media and the world wide web. South Asia Views articulates worldviews, seen from new and fresh perspectives, that of single and singular humanity.

      A unit of RC Foundation

      Head office:
      Burnside Compound, Rilbong,
      Shillong -793004,
      Meghalaya, India.
      Phone no : +91 -364 2223616
      Email : viewssouthasia@gmail.com

      We’re on Facebook

      Quick Navigation

      © 2021 South Asia Views. All Rights Reserved. Empanelled to DIPR, Govt. of Meghalaya vide Order No. ML.13/2007/249 dated 16/10/2017

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • State
      • North East
      • National
      • South Asia
      • Business
      • Sports
      • Opinion
      • Meghalaya Tourism

      © 2021 South Asia Views. All Rights Reserved. Empanelled to DIPR, Govt. of Meghalaya vide Order No. ML.13/2007/249 dated 16/10/2017